National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health, Australian National University, Canberra, Australia
Copyright © 2025 The Korean Society for Preventive Medicine
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Conflict of Interest
The author has no conflicts of interest associated with the material presented in this paper.
Funding
None.
Author Contributions
All work was done by FWD.
Acknowledgements
This research was conducted as part of an internship with the Australian National Internships Program at the Australian National University (ANU), under the guidance of Ms. Zoe Pollock, Dr. Louise Freebairn, and Mr. Glenn Draper from the ACT Health Directorate. The author also extends gratitude to Dr. Dan Chateau and Prof. Philip J. Batterham from ANU, as well as Dr. Indra Yohanes Kiling from Nusa Cendana University (Indonesia), for their additional mentorship. The author received the Australia Awards scholarship to support his postgraduate studies at ANU.
Study | Participants and location | Study design and statistical analysis | Outcome measures | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Self-harm and suicide | Healthcare interactions | |||
Borschmann et al., 2017 [18] | 1307 ex-prisoners in Queensland, Australia |
Longitudinal design Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD with additional review using the Moran approach) History of suicide attempts History of self-harm Flagged for risk of self-harm in prison |
Self-harm presentation in ED Previous hospitalization |
Borschmann et al., 2017 [19] | 1309 ex-prisoners in Queensland, Australia |
Longitudinal design Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ambulance code with additional review using the Moran approach) History of suicide attempts History of self-harm Flagged for risk of self-harm in prison |
Self-harm presentation in an ambulance setting Previous hospitalization |
Carr et al., 2017 [8] | 30 017 people (in the self-harm cohort) vs.600 258 people (in the comparison control group) from the general population who visited primary healthcare centers in England, UK |
Longitudinal design Cox regression survival analysis Correlation of self-harm with suicide death |
Self-harm (Read code) Suicide death (ICD) |
Self-harm presentation at a primary healthcare center |
Cerel et al., 2016 [40] | 171 patients who died by suicide within 6 wk of an ED visit vs. 872 control participants in Kentucky, USA |
Longitudinal design Prevalence study Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) |
ED attendance Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Chitty et al., 2023 [24] | 3895 suicide deaths among the general population in New South Wales, Australia |
Longitudinal design Longitudinal, 3-dimensional k-means cluster analysis was used to categorize participants into 5 groups |
Self-harm (ICD) Suicide death (ICD; final outcome) |
Various types of healthcare contact, including physical, mental, and medicinal use |
Clapperton et al., 2021 [28] | 4348 members of the general population who died by suicide in Victoria, Australia |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (VSR [ICD or unique personal code]) Suicide death (VSR; final outcome) |
History of hospital presentation for any reason, mental health problem, or self-harm |
Clapperton et al., 2023 [29] | 3689 self-harming females and girls (age range, 10–24 y) from the general population in Victoria, Australia |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (VSR) Self-harm method Suicide death Suicidal ideation Self-harm escalation |
Self-harm presentation (ICD) Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional (ICD) |
DelPozo-Banos et al., 2018 [34] | 2604 individuals who died by suicide vs. 52 080 control individuals from the general population in Wales, UK |
Longitudinal design Artificial neural networks Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (Read code or ICD depending on the database utilized) Suicide death |
Presentation of various mental illnesses in primary healthcare (ICD) Previous hospitalization |
Dougall et al., 2014 [33] | 16 411 suicide deaths, collected from the general population in Scotland, UK | Comparative analysis of percentages without p-value testing | Suicide death (ICD; death with unclear cause was not classified as suicide) | Treatment at general vs. psychiatric hospital vs. no treatment at hospital |
Duncan et al., 2019 [27] | 6802 mental health or self-harm–coded patients that utilize ambulance services in Scotland, UK |
Prevalence study Comparative analysis of percentage without p-value testing |
Self-harm (ambulance code) Self-harm method Suicide attempt (ambulance code) Suicide death |
Ambulance use for mental health crisis or self-harm |
Geulayov et al., 2023 [21] | 54 999 self-harm presentations among 31 419 individuals from the general population in England, UK |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression |
Self-harm episode as the unit of analysis (MSSH code) Self-harm method Site of self-harm in the body (MSSH code) Suicide death (ICD) History of self-harm |
Presentation of self-harm in the hospital History of psychiatric care |
Hawton et al., 2020 [22] | 9173 children and adolescents who experienced 13 175 presentations for self-harm in England, UK |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Age at first presentation for self-harm Method of self-harm (MSSH code) Suicide death (ICD) History of self-harm |
Presentation of self-harm at the hospital |
Hu et al., 2016 [39] | 6768 adolescents (10–19 y old) and 10 198 young adults (20–29 y old) admitted to the hospital for self-harm in Western Australia |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm method (ICD) Self-harm (ICD) History of self-harm (ICD) |
Presentation of self-harm at the healthcare center Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Kvaran et al., 2015 [43] | 152 individuals who died by suicide vs. 1520 control participants in Iceland |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) |
Frequency of ED visits Diagnosis received in ED visits (ICD) |
Leckning et al., 2023 [5] | Aboriginal (n=2304) vs. non-Aboriginal (n=2087) patients admitted to the hospital for suicidal ideation or self-harm in the Northern Territory of Australia |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method Suicidal ideation (ICD) Subsequent self-harm after initial visit for self-harm (ICD) Suicide death (ICD) |
History of hospitalization Diagnosis during index hospital admission (ICD) |
Lee et al., 2022 [42] | 974 cases (individuals with psychiatric disorders and suicide risk who died by suicide) vs. 2922 control-matched participants (those with psychiatric disorders and suicide risk who did not die by suicide) in Korea |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes Interaction analysis (this was the only study to use this method) |
Suicide death (ICD) |
Continuity of psychiatric care (Bice-Boxerman formula) Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional (ICD) Length of hospitalization Medication use |
Lee et al., 2023 [25] |
1 830 441 individuals from the general population with psychiatric diagnoses in Korea Patients over 15 y old who were newly diagnosed with severe mental illness using the KCD |
Longitudinal design Cox regression survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (KCD) |
Various types of healthcare use: psychiatric vs. non-psychiatric and inpatient vs. outpatient care Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional (KCD) |
Mallon et al., 2019 [31] | 60 males and boys with no previous healthcare contact 1 y before suicide, collected from the general male population in North Ireland, UK | Comparative analysis of percentage without p-value testing | Suicide death (categorization not clear) | History of contact with healthcare in the year before suicide death |
Morgan et al., 2017 [35] | 16 912 children and adolescents who self-harmed in England, UK |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Chi-square test Correlation of self-harm with suicide death |
Self-harm (ICD & Read coding) Suicide death (ICD) |
Presentation for self-harm within healthcare system Received referral to mental health experts Received psychotropic drugs |
Munasinghe et al., 2022 [37] | 19 437 referrals from the general population in Western Sydney, New South Wales, Australia |
Prevalence study Comparative analysis of percentages without p-value testing |
Self-harm (categorization not clear) Flagged as being at suicide risk |
No. of treatment sessions Waiting time for first treatment session Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Myhre et al., 2024 [9] | 830 people who died by suicide, collected from the general population in Norway |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression State sequence analysis Cluster analysis used to group participants Chi-square test t-test Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) History of self-harm (ICD) |
Categorization of participants based on their contact patterns History of receiving inpatient and outpatient service for mental health or substance use disorder |
Park et al., 2022 [44] | 74 741 people who died by suicide, collected from the general population in Korea |
Longitudinal design Chi-square test Comparison of proportions of healthcare visits Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) | Interaction with various types of healthcare: psychiatric vs. non-psychiatric |
Pham et al., 2023 [23] | 42 127 patients aged 15 and older who self-harm, collected from the general population in Victoria, Australia |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes This was the only study to use 2 types of statistical analysis methods to study the same outcome (OR and IRR) |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method Self-harm location |
Index admission for self-harm (ICD) Hospital readmission for self-harm or injury Mental health service contact after index admission Length of hospitalization |
Schaffer et al., 2016 [6] | 2835 people who died by suicide, collected from the general population in Ontario, Canada |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Logistic regression Comparison of proportions of healthcare visits Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (categorization not clear) Suicide method Suicide location |
Various types of mental healthcare interactions, including emergency visits, outpatient psychiatry, etc. |
Spittal et al., 2017 [41] | 42 353 individuals hospitalized for self-harm, collected from the general population in New South Wales, Australia |
Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method History of self-harm |
Index admission to hospital due to self-harm History of receiving community mental health care Future use of community mental health care Length of hospitalization Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Vuagnat et al., 2019 [7] | 136 451 participants, 1231 of whom died by suicide, from the general population in France |
Longitudinal design Survival analysis Standardized mortality ratio analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (categorization not clear) Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method |
Initial presentation of self-harm at hospital Length of hospitalization Treatment at university hospital vs. general hospital vs. private clinic Transfer history to other department within hospital |
Young et al., 2020 [20] | 217 ex-prisoners who received acute care in Queensland, Australia |
Longitudinal design Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method Flagged for risk of self-harm in prison |
Presentation of self-harm in ambulance, ED, and hospital Contact with mental health services History of mental health service use |
Study | Participants and location | Study design and statistical analysis | Outcome measures | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Self-harm and suicide | Healthcare interactions | |||
Borschmann et al., 2017 [ |
1307 ex-prisoners in Queensland, Australia | Longitudinal design Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD with additional review using the Moran approach) History of suicide attempts History of self-harm Flagged for risk of self-harm in prison |
Self-harm presentation in ED Previous hospitalization |
Borschmann et al., 2017 [ |
1309 ex-prisoners in Queensland, Australia | Longitudinal design Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ambulance code with additional review using the Moran approach) History of suicide attempts History of self-harm Flagged for risk of self-harm in prison |
Self-harm presentation in an ambulance setting Previous hospitalization |
Carr et al., 2017 [ |
30 017 people (in the self-harm cohort) vs.600 258 people (in the comparison control group) from the general population who visited primary healthcare centers in England, UK | Longitudinal design Cox regression survival analysis Correlation of self-harm with suicide death |
Self-harm (Read code) Suicide death (ICD) |
Self-harm presentation at a primary healthcare center |
Cerel et al., 2016 [ |
171 patients who died by suicide within 6 wk of an ED visit vs. 872 control participants in Kentucky, USA | Longitudinal design Prevalence study Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) | ED attendance Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Chitty et al., 2023 [ |
3895 suicide deaths among the general population in New South Wales, Australia | Longitudinal design Longitudinal, 3-dimensional k-means cluster analysis was used to categorize participants into 5 groups |
Self-harm (ICD) Suicide death (ICD; final outcome) |
Various types of healthcare contact, including physical, mental, and medicinal use |
Clapperton et al., 2021 [ |
4348 members of the general population who died by suicide in Victoria, Australia | Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (VSR [ICD or unique personal code]) Suicide death (VSR; final outcome) |
History of hospital presentation for any reason, mental health problem, or self-harm |
Clapperton et al., 2023 [ |
3689 self-harming females and girls (age range, 10–24 y) from the general population in Victoria, Australia | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (VSR) Self-harm method Suicide death Suicidal ideation Self-harm escalation |
Self-harm presentation (ICD) Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional (ICD) |
DelPozo-Banos et al., 2018 [ |
2604 individuals who died by suicide vs. 52 080 control individuals from the general population in Wales, UK | Longitudinal design Artificial neural networks Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (Read code or ICD depending on the database utilized) Suicide death |
Presentation of various mental illnesses in primary healthcare (ICD) Previous hospitalization |
Dougall et al., 2014 [ |
16 411 suicide deaths, collected from the general population in Scotland, UK | Comparative analysis of percentages without p-value testing | Suicide death (ICD; death with unclear cause was not classified as suicide) | Treatment at general vs. psychiatric hospital vs. no treatment at hospital |
Duncan et al., 2019 [ |
6802 mental health or self-harm–coded patients that utilize ambulance services in Scotland, UK | Prevalence study Comparative analysis of percentage without p-value testing |
Self-harm (ambulance code) Self-harm method Suicide attempt (ambulance code) Suicide death |
Ambulance use for mental health crisis or self-harm |
Geulayov et al., 2023 [ |
54 999 self-harm presentations among 31 419 individuals from the general population in England, UK | Longitudinal design Logistic regression |
Self-harm episode as the unit of analysis (MSSH code) Self-harm method Site of self-harm in the body (MSSH code) Suicide death (ICD) History of self-harm |
Presentation of self-harm in the hospital History of psychiatric care |
Hawton et al., 2020 [ |
9173 children and adolescents who experienced 13 175 presentations for self-harm in England, UK | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Age at first presentation for self-harm Method of self-harm (MSSH code) Suicide death (ICD) History of self-harm |
Presentation of self-harm at the hospital |
Hu et al., 2016 [ |
6768 adolescents (10–19 y old) and 10 198 young adults (20–29 y old) admitted to the hospital for self-harm in Western Australia | Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm method (ICD) Self-harm (ICD) History of self-harm (ICD) |
Presentation of self-harm at the healthcare center Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Kvaran et al., 2015 [ |
152 individuals who died by suicide vs. 1520 control participants in Iceland | Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) | Frequency of ED visits Diagnosis received in ED visits (ICD) |
Leckning et al., 2023 [ |
Aboriginal (n=2304) vs. non-Aboriginal (n=2087) patients admitted to the hospital for suicidal ideation or self-harm in the Northern Territory of Australia | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method Suicidal ideation (ICD) Subsequent self-harm after initial visit for self-harm (ICD) Suicide death (ICD) |
History of hospitalization Diagnosis during index hospital admission (ICD) |
Lee et al., 2022 [ |
974 cases (individuals with psychiatric disorders and suicide risk who died by suicide) vs. 2922 control-matched participants (those with psychiatric disorders and suicide risk who did not die by suicide) in Korea | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes Interaction analysis (this was the only study to use this method) |
Suicide death (ICD) | Continuity of psychiatric care (Bice-Boxerman formula) Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional (ICD) Length of hospitalization Medication use |
Lee et al., 2023 [ |
1 830 441 individuals from the general population with psychiatric diagnoses in Korea Patients over 15 y old who were newly diagnosed with severe mental illness using the KCD |
Longitudinal design Cox regression survival analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (KCD) | Various types of healthcare use: psychiatric vs. non-psychiatric and inpatient vs. outpatient care Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional (KCD) |
Mallon et al., 2019 [ |
60 males and boys with no previous healthcare contact 1 y before suicide, collected from the general male population in North Ireland, UK | Comparative analysis of percentage without p-value testing | Suicide death (categorization not clear) | History of contact with healthcare in the year before suicide death |
Morgan et al., 2017 [ |
16 912 children and adolescents who self-harmed in England, UK | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Chi-square test Correlation of self-harm with suicide death |
Self-harm (ICD & Read coding) Suicide death (ICD) |
Presentation for self-harm within healthcare system Received referral to mental health experts Received psychotropic drugs |
Munasinghe et al., 2022 [ |
19 437 referrals from the general population in Western Sydney, New South Wales, Australia | Prevalence study Comparative analysis of percentages without p-value testing |
Self-harm (categorization not clear) Flagged as being at suicide risk |
No. of treatment sessions Waiting time for first treatment session Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Myhre et al., 2024 [ |
830 people who died by suicide, collected from the general population in Norway | Longitudinal design Logistic regression State sequence analysis Cluster analysis used to group participants Chi-square test t-test Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) History of self-harm (ICD) |
Categorization of participants based on their contact patterns History of receiving inpatient and outpatient service for mental health or substance use disorder |
Park et al., 2022 [ |
74 741 people who died by suicide, collected from the general population in Korea | Longitudinal design Chi-square test Comparison of proportions of healthcare visits Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (ICD) | Interaction with various types of healthcare: psychiatric vs. non-psychiatric |
Pham et al., 2023 [ |
42 127 patients aged 15 and older who self-harm, collected from the general population in Victoria, Australia | Longitudinal design Logistic regression Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes This was the only study to use 2 types of statistical analysis methods to study the same outcome (OR and IRR) |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method Self-harm location |
Index admission for self-harm (ICD) Hospital readmission for self-harm or injury Mental health service contact after index admission Length of hospitalization |
Schaffer et al., 2016 [ |
2835 people who died by suicide, collected from the general population in Ontario, Canada | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Logistic regression Comparison of proportions of healthcare visits Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (categorization not clear) Suicide method Suicide location |
Various types of mental healthcare interactions, including emergency visits, outpatient psychiatry, etc. |
Spittal et al., 2017 [ |
42 353 individuals hospitalized for self-harm, collected from the general population in New South Wales, Australia | Longitudinal design Logistic regression Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method History of self-harm |
Index admission to hospital due to self-harm History of receiving community mental health care Future use of community mental health care Length of hospitalization Receipt of psychiatric diagnosis from a professional |
Vuagnat et al., 2019 [ |
136 451 participants, 1231 of whom died by suicide, from the general population in France | Longitudinal design Survival analysis Standardized mortality ratio analysis Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Suicide death (categorization not clear) Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method |
Initial presentation of self-harm at hospital Length of hospitalization Treatment at university hospital vs. general hospital vs. private clinic Transfer history to other department within hospital |
Young et al., 2020 [ |
217 ex-prisoners who received acute care in Queensland, Australia | Longitudinal design Negative binomial/Poisson regression (count/rate) Correlation of socio-demographic characteristics and suicide/self-harm/health-related outcomes |
Self-harm (ICD) Self-harm method Flagged for risk of self-harm in prison |
Presentation of self-harm in ambulance, ED, and hospital Contact with mental health services History of mental health service use |
ICD, International Classification of Diseases; ED, emergency department; VSR, Victorian Suicide Register; MSSH, Multicentre Study of Self-Harm; DSH, deliberate self-harm; KCD, Korean Classification of Diseases; OR, odds ratio; IRR, incident risk ratio.