Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

JPMPH : Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health

OPEN ACCESS
SEARCH
Search

Articles

Page Path
HOME > J Prev Med Public Health > Volume 59(5); 2026 > Article
Original Article
Comparative Risk Perceptions of Alternative Nicotine Products Among People Who Smoke Cigarettes and Dual Products: Findings From the 2024 ITC Korea Survey
Hoang Le Tu1,2orcid, Jin-Kyoung Oh1orcid, Hong-Gwan Seo3orcid, Gil-Yong Kim4orcid, Sung-il Cho5,6orcid, Sungkyu Lee7orcid, Yeol Kim1,8orcid, Gang Meng9orcid, Anne C. K. Quah9orcid, Geoffrey T. Fong9,10,11orcid, Yoon-Jung Choi1orcid
Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health 2026;59(5):519-530.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3961/jpmph.26.338
Published online: September 1, 2026
  • 1,717 Views
  • 58 Download

1Department of Public Health & AI, Graduate School of Cancer Science and Policy, National Cancer Center, Goyang, Korea

2Department of Biostatistics Hanoi University of Public Health, Hanoi, Vietnam

3Department of Disease Screening, Design Hospital, Jeonju, Korea

4National Tobacco Control Center, Korean Health Promotion Institute, Seoul, Korea

5Department of Public Health Science, Graduate School of Public Health, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea

6Institute of Health and Environment, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea

7Korea Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea

8Department of Family Medicine, National Cancer Center, Goyang, Korea

9Department of Psychology, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada

10School of Public Health Sciences, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada

11Ontario Institute for Cancer Research, Toronto, ON, Canada

Corresponding author: Yoon-Jung Choi, Department of Public Health & AI, Graduate School of Cancer Science and Policy, National Cancer Center, 323 Ilsan-ro, Ilsandong-gu, Goyang 10408, Korea, E-mail: yj_choi@ncc.re.kr
• Received: April 15, 2026   • Revised: July 7, 2026   • Accepted: August 3, 2026

Copyright © 2026 The Korean Society for Preventive Medicine

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

prev next
  • Objectives
    Heated tobacco products (HTPs) and electronic cigarettes (ECs) have rapidly expanded in Korea. This study aimed to examine differences in comparative risk perceptions of HTPs and ECs relative to cigarettes among Korean adults and to identify factors associated with these perceptions.
  • Methods
    Data were drawn from the KRA4–Cohort 3 dataset of the nationally representative International Tobacco Control Korea Survey and were analyzed for respondents who currently used cigarettes, HTPs, or ECs. Two ordinal outcomes measured perceived comparative harm of HTPs and ECs relative to cigarettes. Multivariable Bayesian ordinal logistic regression models were fitted, and robustness was assessed using Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings and frequentist sensitivity analyses.
  • Results
    Compared with cigarette-only users, respondents who used both cigarettes and HTPs had lower odds of perceiving HTPs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 0.43; 95% credible interval [CrI], 0.36 to 0.50). Similarly, respondents who used both cigarettes and ECs had lower odds of perceiving ECs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (aOR, 0.31; 95% CrI, 0.19 to 0.47). Adults aged 40–59 years had higher odds of perceiving both products as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (HTPs: aOR, 1.35; 95% CrI, 1.12 to 1.61; ECs: aOR, 1.42; 95% CrI, 1.18 to 1.73). Noticing tobacco advertising was associated with lower perceived harm. Findings were consistent across the 3 analytic approaches.
  • Conclusions
    Lower perceived harm of HTPs and ECs relative to cigarettes was common among Korean adults who smoked cigarettes, especially among dual-product users and those exposed to marketing. Stronger advertising regulation, standardized warnings, and comparative risk education are needed to address misperceptions about relative harmfulness and support cessation.
Heated tobacco products (HTPs) were introduced to the Korean market in 2017 and quickly captured a substantial share of national tobacco sales [1]. The rapid expansion of HTPs occurred alongside widespread use of electronic cigarettes (ECs), creating a market in which many adults use cigarettes alongside non-combustible tobacco or nicotine products [2,3]. Recent studies have reported that more than one-third of Korean adults who use cigarettes have engaged in some form of dual or poly-use [2].
According to the Health Belief Model and the Risk Perception Attitude Framework, perceptions of susceptibility and severity influence health-related behaviors, including tobacco initiation, product switching, and cessation [4–6]. Although most research has focused on absolute risk perceptions—that is, whether a product is harmful in itself—comparative risk perceptions, or judgments about how harmful one product is relative to another, may be more influential in behavioral decisions such as substitution or dual use [3].
Although studies in North America and Europe have documented risk perceptions toward ECs and, more recently, HTPs [7–9], evidence directly comparing perceptions across both products remains limited, particularly among people who smoke and use other tobacco or nicotine products. Such evidence is also scarce in Korea, where both products are heavily marketed and widely available. Using the 2020 International Tobacco Control (ITC) Korea Survey, Goulette et al. [3] reported that 27.5% of adults who smoked believed HTPs were less harmful than cigarettes and that 23.4% believed nicotine vaping products were less harmful than cigarettes; cigarette-only smokers were less likely than dual or triple users to hold these beliefs that HTPs and ECs are less harmful than cigarettes. The Korean tobacco market therefore provides an important setting in which to examine how people who use cigarettes, HTPs, and ECs, alone or in combination, perceive comparative health risks and to inform regulatory decisions regarding product communication, packaging, and marketing restrictions [10].
This study therefore aimed to: (1) measure how perceptions of the relative harmfulness of HTPs and ECs compared with cigarettes differ between Korean adults who use only cigarettes and those who use cigarettes plus HTPs or ECs; and (2) examine whether findings on the perceived relative harmfulness of HTPs and ECs are consistent across different statistical approaches.
Study Design and Data Source
This cross-sectional study analyzed the KRA4–Cohort 3 dataset of the ITC Korea Survey, a nationally representative longitudinal cohort of adults in Korea. Data were collected between February 2024 and April 2024. Detailed descriptions of the sample and methods have been reported elsewhere [11,12].
Study Participants
Eligible participants were adults aged ≥19 years who currently used any type of cigarette and had information on product use status and comparative risk perception outcomes. To define mutually exclusive product use groups centered on cigarette smoking, respondents who used all 3 products and those who used only HTPs or only ECs were excluded. The remaining respondents were classified into 3 mutually exclusive groups: cigarette-only users (SC), defined as respondents who currently smoked cigarettes but did not currently use HTPs or ECs; dual users of cigarettes and HTPs (SC+HTP), defined as respondents who currently used both cigarettes and HTPs but did not currently use ECs; and dual users of cigarettes and ECs (SC+EC), defined as respondents who currently used both cigarettes and ECs but did not currently use HTPs. Among 3243 eligible respondents, 233 were further excluded because data were missing for comparative risk perception outcomes or covariates included in the regression models. The final analytic sample included 3010 respondents: SC (n=1801), dual users of cigarettes and HTPs (SC+HTP; n=1156), and dual users of cigarettes and ECs (SC+EC; n=53).
Variables and Measurements
Two primary outcomes assessed comparative risk perceptions, each measured on a 3-level ordinal scale: (1) comparative risk of HTPs versus cigarettes, categorized as “less harmful than cigarettes,” “equally harmful,” or “more harmful”; and (2) comparative risk of ECs versus cigarettes, using the same categories.
Covariates included tobacco-use type, sex, age group (19–39, 40–59, or ≥60 years), education level (≤high school vs. university/postgraduate), and annual household income (<30, 30–75, or >75 million Korean won). Tobacco-use characteristics included the Heaviness of Smoking Index (HSI; 0–1, 2–4, or 5–6), partner/spouse smoking status (yes/no), and alcohol drinking status (yes/no). Additional binary indicators captured self-reported exposure to health warnings and tobacco advertising for cigarettes, HTPs, and ECs. The models also adjusted for time in sample (1–4), defined as the number of survey waves previously completed.
Statistical Analysis

Descriptive statistics and univariable analysis

Unweighted means and standard deviations were calculated for continuous variables, and unweighted percentages were calculated for categorical variables by cigarette-use type. Univariable associations between comparative risk perceptions and study characteristics were assessed using survey-weighted likelihood-ratio tests for categorical variables. Some covariates had additional item-level missing data; therefore, descriptive denominators varied by variable, and multivariable regression models were estimated using complete cases for the variables included in each model.

Multivariable Bayesian analysis

Bayesian ordinal logistic regression with the Metropolis-Hastings algorithm was used as the primary modeling approach for 3 reasons. First, the outcomes were ordinal comparative risk perception measures, and Bayesian estimation allowed uncertainty to be expressed directly through posterior distributions and credible intervals (CrIs) [13]. Second, some product use groups, particularly dual users of cigarettes and ECs, were relatively small, making a Bayesian framework useful for improving estimation stability and reducing reliance on large-sample asymptotic approximations [13]. Third, Bayesian estimation allowed the robustness of findings to be examined under different prior assumptions, including weakly informative priors and informative priors based on previous ITC analyses and related studies. Conventional survey-weighted ordinal logistic regression was retained as a sensitivity analysis to assess whether the main conclusions were consistent with a design-based frequentist approach for complex survey data [14].
Multivariable Bayesian ordinal regression models were fitted separately for each outcome to examine associations between product use group and comparative risk perceptions while adjusting for all covariates. Posterior distributions were obtained using Markov chain Monte Carlo methods with 200 000 iterations after a 40 000-iteration burn-in. Convergence was assessed using trace plots and the Gelman-Rubin statistic (R̂ <1.1).
Two Bayesian estimation frameworks were implemented to evaluate the robustness of the inferences.
First, in the standard Bayesian model with non-informative priors, diffuse, or flat, priors were assigned to all regression coefficients (normal [0, 102]). This approach reflected minimal prior knowledge and allowed the posterior distribution to be driven primarily by the observed data.
Second, in the Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings model with informative priors, normal priors centered on parameter estimates from prior ITC analyses and published studies were specified (normal [μprior, σprior2]), reflecting existing evidence about expected effect directions.
Adjusted odds ratios (aORs) and 95% CrIs were derived from the posterior distributions. The 2 Bayesian approaches were compared to assess the stability of effect estimates under different prior assumptions.

Survey weighting

All univariable analyses and frequentist ordered logistic regression models were survey-weighted using the ITC survey design, with Taylor series linearization used for variance estimation. The Bayesian models were fitted without sampling weights because the primary objective was model-based estimation of associations and comparison of posterior uncertainty under alternative prior specifications. To evaluate whether this modeling choice affected the substantive conclusions, Bayesian estimates were compared with survey-weighted frequentist ordinal logistic regression estimates in sensitivity analyses.

Sensitivity analysis

To evaluate robustness, estimates from the primary Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings model with informative priors were compared with those from a Bayesian model using non-informative priors and a survey-weighted frequentist ordinal logistic regression model. The frequentist model was treated as a design-based sensitivity analysis to assess whether accounting for ITC survey weights changed the direction, magnitude, or interpretation of the main associations. Consistency of effect estimates across methods was interpreted as supporting the robustness of the findings.
All analyses were performed in Stata version 19.5 (StataCorp., College Station, TX, USA) using the ologit and bayes commands for Bayesian modeling and the svy command for weighted analyses.
Ethics Statement
The ITC Korea Survey protocols and all related materials, including the survey questionnaires, were approved by the Research Ethics Board of the University of Waterloo, Canada (REB#21287/30768). All participants provided consent to participate in the survey.
Socio-demographic Characteristics of Korean Participants by Type of Cigarette Use
Participant characteristics of the final analytic sample are shown in Table 1. Among the 3010 eligible Korean adults included in the analysis, 59.8% were SC, 38.4% were dual users of cigarettes and HTPs, and 1.8% were dual users of cigarettes and ECs. The overall mean±standard deviation (SD) age was 47.2±11.3 years. Dual-product users were younger than SC: the mean age was 43.9±10.2 years among SC+HTP users and 40.5±12.1 years among SC+EC users, compared with 49.5±11.3 years among SC (p<0.001). Adults aged 19–39 years comprised 43.4% of SC+EC users and 32.4% of SC+HTP users, compared with 18.4% of SC (p<0.001).
Male accounted for 86.5% of the sample, with modest differences by cigarette-use type (p=0.018). Higher education was more common among SC+HTP users than among SC, but it was less common among SC+EC users: 83.9% of SC+HTP users and 50.9% of SC+EC users had a university or postgraduate education, compared with 72.1% of SC (p<0.001). Household income also differed across groups; the proportion of participants in the high-income category was 39.0% among SC+HTP users, 30.8% among SC+EC users, and 29.4% among SC (p<0.001). Regarding survey participation, 41.3% of respondents were participating in the survey for the first time in this wave, whereas 21.5% had participated in all rounds.
Smoking and Product Use Characteristics of Korean Participants by Type of Cigarette Use
Smoking characteristics of respondents are presented in Table 2. Most respondents (90.3%) reported daily cigarette smoking, although the proportion differed significantly across product use groups (p<0.001). Among SC+HTP dual users, 65.7% reported daily HTP use. Among SC+EC dual users, 54.7% reported daily EC use. Approximately 55.9% of respondents had ever tried to quit smoking, with similar proportions among single-product and dual-product users (p=0.348). Most participants had low nicotine dependence: 68.6% had low HSI scores, 30.1% had moderate scores, and only 1.3% had high scores (p<0.001).
Nearly all participants (99.4%) reported exposure to any type of tobacco/nicotine warning. However, noticing advertising differed significantly across cigarette-use groups. Dual users were more likely than SC to have noticed cigarette advertising: 73.6% of SC+EC users and 76.0% of SC+HTP users reported noticing cigarette advertising, compared with 60.5% of SC (p<0.001). Similarly, compared with SC, the corresponding dual-use groups reported greater exposure to HTP and EC advertising: 87.9% of SC+HTP users reported noticing HTP advertisements versus 54.2% of SC, and 92.5% of SC+EC users reported noticing EC advertisements versus 73.6% of SC (p<0.001 for both comparisons).
Associations Between Study Characteristics and Comparative Risk Perceptions
In the univariable analysis (Supplemental Material 1), perceived comparative harm differed significantly by cigarette-use type, age group, and exposure to product advertising for both outcomes (p<0.001). Participants who used HTPs or ECs were more likely to perceive these products as less harmful than cigarettes (p=0.001 and <0.001, respectively). Younger adults aged 19–39 years more frequently perceived both HTPs and ECs as less harmful than cigarettes than did older age groups (p=0.015 for HTPs; p<0.001 for ECs). Exposure to HTP and EC advertising was also associated with perceiving these products as less harmful than cigarettes (both p<0.001). No other variables showed significant associations.
Figure 1 presents the aORs and corresponding 95% CrIs for factors associated with perceived comparative risk of HTPs and ECs relative to cigarettes. Compared with SC, participants who used both cigarettes and HTPs had lower odds of perceiving HTPs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (aOR, 0.43; 95% CrI, 0.36 to 0.50). Similarly, participants who used both cigarettes and ECs had lower odds of perceiving ECs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (aOR, 0.31; 95% CrI, 0.19 to 0.47).
Age was positively associated with higher perceived risk. Adults aged 40–59 years were more likely than those aged 19–39 years to perceive both HTPs (aOR, 1.35; 95% CrI, 1.12 to 1.61) and ECs (aOR, 1.42; 95% CrI, 1.18 to 1.73) as equally or more harmful than cigarettes. This pattern was also observed among adults aged ≥60 years for ECs (aOR, 1.41; 95% CrI, 1.08 to 1.83), whereas the corresponding association for HTPs was weaker and included the null value (aOR, 1.16; 95% CrI, 0.91 to 1.45). Noticing cigarette advertising was associated with lower odds of perceiving HTPs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (aOR, 0.60; 95% CrI, 0.49 to 0.73), and noticing EC advertising was similarly associated with lower odds of perceiving ECs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes (aOR, 0.71; 95% CrI, 0.53 to 0.92). Sex, household income, partner smoking status, and noticing HTP advertising were not significantly associated with comparative risk perceptions after adjustment for other covariates.
Sensitivity Analysis Across Analytical Approaches
Across both outcomes, the unweighted Bayesian, Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings, and survey-weighted frequentist models produced similar estimates with overlapping 95% CrIs or 95% confidence intervals (CIs) (Figure 2), suggesting that the main substantive conclusions were not materially changed after accounting for ITC survey weights in the frequentist sensitivity analysis. For HTPs versus cigarettes (Figure 2A), respondents who used both cigarettes and HTPs had consistently lower odds of perceiving HTPs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes across the Bayesian model (aOR, 0.44; 95% CrI, 0.39 to 0.50), Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings model (aOR, 0.43; 95% CrI, 0.36 to 0.50), and frequentist model (aOR, 0.47; 95% CI, 0.37 to 0.60). Adults aged 40–59 years were more likely to perceive HTPs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes across the Bayesian model (aOR, 1.40; 95% CrI, 1.19 to 1.65), Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings model (aOR, 1.35; 95% CrI, 1.12 to 1.61), and frequentist model (aOR, 1.42; 95% CI, 1.04 to 1.95).
For ECs versus cigarettes (Figure 2B), respondents who used both cigarettes and ECs showed a similar pattern across the Bayesian model (aOR, 0.25; 95% CrI, 0.18 to 0.34), Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings model (aOR, 0.31; 95% CrI, 0.19 to 0.47), and frequentist model (aOR, 0.34; 95% CI, 0.17 to 0.72). Exposure to EC advertising was negatively associated with perceived harm in the Bayesian models, with the same directional pattern but greater uncertainty in the frequentist model: Bayesian model (aOR, 0.77; 95% CrI, 0.64 to 0.92), Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings model (aOR, 0.71; 95% CrI, 0.56 to 0.88), and frequentist model (aOR, 0.88; 95% CI, 0.55 to 1.41). Detailed results are presented in Supplemental Material 2.
Key Findings of This Study
This study found that dual-use respondents were less likely than SC to perceive HTPs and ECs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes, indicating lower perceived relative harm for these products. Specifically, respondents who used both cigarettes and HTPs had lower odds of perceiving HTPs as equally or more harmful, and those who used both cigarettes and ECs showed a similar pattern. Older adults, particularly those aged 40–59 years, were also more likely to report higher harm perceptions toward both products. In addition, noticing product advertising was consistently associated with lower perceived harm, suggesting that marketing may influence public risk beliefs. Sensitivity analyses comparing Bayesian, Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings, and frequentist models produced similar estimates with overlapping 95% CrIs or 95% CIs, supporting the robustness of these associations.
Comparative Risk Perception of Heated Tobacco Products Versus Cigarettes
This study showed that perceptions of HTPs varied systematically by smoking status, age, and exposure to tobacco marketing. Respondents who used both cigarettes and HTPs had significantly lower odds of perceiving HTPs as equally or more harmful than cigarettes, consistent with studies from Japan and other ITC countries showing that people who use cigarettes with HTPs or ECs frequently endorse harm-reduction beliefs that may justify continued use [3,15]. This pattern may reflect cognitive adaptation: people who use more than 1 tobacco product may rationalize HTP use as safer, thereby reinforcing continued tobacco consumption rather than cessation [16]. In the 2024 estimates, one-quarter of respondents perceived HTPs as less harmful than cigarettes (25.1%), while most selected “equally harmful” (66.8%). In addition, “don’t know” responses were relatively uncommon for HTPs versus cigarettes (4.1%), suggesting that the large “equally harmful” share in 2024 largely reflected endorsement of equivalence rather than uncertainty. This distinction matters because, when “don’t know” responses are rare, the “equally harmful” category is less likely to serve as a proxy for indecision and more likely to represent a belief that HTPs are not meaningfully safer than cigarettes.
Age was another strong predictor of perceived risk. Adults aged 40–59 years were more likely than younger adults to perceive HTPs as equally or more harmful; a similar but weaker pattern was observed among adults aged ≥60 years. This finding echoes evidence from other Asian countries that younger people who use tobacco may adopt heated products as “cleaner” or “healthier” alternatives to cigarettes [17,18]. These findings suggest that lower perceived harm among younger adults who smoke may be related to age-specific health concerns and targeted marketing that portrays HTPs as advanced and “reduced-risk” technologies [8]. Noticing cigarette advertising was associated with lower perceived harm of HTPs relative to cigarettes, whereas noticing HTP advertising was not significantly associated with HTP comparative risk perceptions after adjustment. This finding suggests that broader tobacco advertising exposure, rather than HTP-specific advertising alone, may be related to comparative harm perceptions. Previous Korean evidence has similarly reported associations between tobacco marketing exposure and lower perceived product harmfulness or greater product appeal [19]. Given that Korea permits point-of-sale promotion and product display for HTPs, this marketing environment may amplify perceptions of reduced harm [1]. These descriptive results are broadly consistent with Goulette et al. [3] (ITC Korea Wave 1, June 2020), in which 27.5% of respondents perceived HTPs as less harmful than cigarettes and 11.2% responded “don’t know”. In the 2024 data, “don’t know” responses were less frequent (4.1%), which may indicate reduced uncertainty and a shift toward endorsing “equally harmful.”
Comparative Risk Perception of Electronic cigarettes Versus Cigarettes
Consistent patterns were observed for ECs: respondents who used both cigarettes and ECs were markedly more likely to perceive ECs as less harmful than cigarettes, consistent with previous findings from the ITC Project and national surveys in the United States and Korea [3,20]. Among dual users, these perceptions may reflect post-use justification or selective exposure to pro-vaping information, both of which can normalize continued dual use rather than cessation [21]. Age differences were again evident: adults aged 40–59 years who smoked were more likely than younger adults to consider ECs more harmful. This finding aligns with evidence from the United States linking older age to greater perceived relative risk of ECs, although trends from England show rising perceptions that ECs are more harmful or equally harmful across all ages, with the sharpest recent increases among younger adults, suggesting country-specific dynamics [22,23]. In the 2024 estimates, 19.1% of respondents perceived ECs as less harmful than cigarettes, while most selected “equally harmful” (68.7%). “Don’t know” responses were more common for ECs than for HTPs (7.7% for ECs vs. cigarettes) but remained substantially less common than “equally harmful” responses, indicating that beliefs about equivalent harm, rather than uncertainty alone, accounted for much of the observed distribution. This suggests that many respondents may not perceive a meaningful harm gradient between ECs and cigarettes, which is important because an “equally harmful” belief is less consistent with switching away from cigarettes for harm reduction and may instead support continued dual use or attitudes that switching offers no benefit.
Public Health and Policy Implications
In Korea, lower perceived harm of HTPs and ECs relative to cigarettes among people who use cigarettes plus HTPs or ECs may contribute to continued multi-product tobacco or nicotine use rather than complete cessation. Consistent with behavioral theory and international evidence, people who use these products and view them as less harmful may have lower quit intentions and a higher likelihood of maintaining dual use [3,20,24]. Since the introduction of HTPs in 2017, the Korean tobacco market has rapidly evolved into a dual-product environment, in which many adults alternate between cigarettes and newer products because they believe these products reduce health risks [1]. This perception may weaken motivation to quit, particularly among adults who interpret “reduced exposure” claims as “reduced harm.” Exposure to marketing that frames HTPs and ECs as “smoke-free,” “clean,” or “advanced technology” may further amplify these beliefs, as shown in Korean and international studies [2].
Comparative risk perceptions in Korea may be formed through several overlapping information channels. Advertising and point-of-sale promotion can frame HTPs and ECs around novelty, cleanliness, reduced smell, and technological features, while online retailers and e-commerce platforms may further reinforce safety-related or health-related claims. Korean evidence suggests that online HTP and EC retailers commonly use promotional claims related to safety and health, and ITC Korea data have shown that advertising exposure is associated with lower perceived harmfulness of these products relative to cigarettes [3,25]. Beyond formal marketing, online communities, social media, and peer communication may also shape perceptions through informal product reviews and shared experiences regarding smell, convenience, indoor use, and perceived bodily effects. These pathways suggest that future tobacco control responses should include monitoring online marketing, correcting misleading comparative claims, and developing risk-communication strategies tailored to the information channels through which adult users encounter HTP and EC messages.
These findings have clear implications for tobacco control in Korea. Regulations should reduce gaps between cigarettes and alternative products by strengthening measures aligned with the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, including restrictions on misleading promotion and standardized packaging for HTPs and ECs.
A key strength of this study was its use of multiple analytic frameworks. Bayesian ordinal logistic regression allowed probabilistic estimation of uncertainty and robustness checks under alternative prior assumptions, while comparison with survey-weighted frequentist ordinal logistic regression showed that the main findings were not dependent on a single modeling framework.
Several limitations should be noted. The cross-sectional design precludes causal inference, and self-reported measures may be subject to recall and social desirability bias. Advertising exposure was measured broadly, without details on frequency or channel, and biochemical validation of product use was not available. Although the sample was nationally representative, young adults and intermittent users were underrepresented in the analytic sample, and residual confounding, such as exposure to health campaigns or trust in health messaging, may remain. Comparisons with Goulette et al. [3] (ITC Korea Wave 1, 2020) should be interpreted cautiously because of differences in outcome categorization and analytic samples. “Don’t know” responses were more common in 2020 (11.2% for HTPs; 13.9% for nicotine vaping products) than in the present analysis (4.1 and 7.7%, respectively), and Goulette et al. included triple users, whereas the present study excluded them. Finally, Bayesian models were fitted without sampling weights; therefore, the Bayesian estimates should be interpreted as model-based adjusted associations rather than design-based nationally representative estimates. However, survey-weighted frequentist ordinal logistic regression produced similar effect estimates and did not materially change the interpretation of the main findings.
Supplemental materials are available at https://doi.org/10.3961/jpmph.26.338.

Supplemental Material 1.

Associations between study characteristics and comparative risk perceptions of HTPs and e-cigarettes vs. cigarettes, 2024 ITC Korea Survey
jpmph-26-338-Supplementary-Material-1.docx

Supplemental Material 2.

Sensitivity analysis comparing adjusted associations for comparative risk perceptions of HTPs and e-cigarettes vs. cigarettes across three analytical approaches, 2024 ITC Korea Survey
jpmph-26-338-Supplementary-Material-2.docx

Conflict of Interest

The authors have no conflicts of interest associated with the material presented in this paper.

Funding

The ITC Korea Surveys (third cohort) were supported by a grant from the Republic of Korea National Health Promotion Fund and the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (FDN-148477). Additional support was provided by the US National Cancer Institute (P01 CA200512). Additional support to GTF was provided by a Senior Investigator Grant from the Ontario Institute for Cancer Research (2002-present), and a Senior Prevention Scientist Award from the Canadian Cancer Society Research Institute (2002–2009) and O. Harold Warwick Prize (2021).

Acknowledgements

The funders had no role in the design of the study; in the collection, analyses, or interpretation of data; in the writing of the manuscript, or in the decision to publish the results.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization: Quah ACK, Fong GT, Choi YJ, Oh JK, Le Tu H. Data curation: Le Tu H. Quah ACK, Fong GT, Choi YJ, Oh JK, Seo HG, Kim GY, Cho SI, Lee S, Kim Y, Meng G. Formal analysis: Le Tu H, Oh JK. Funding acquisition: Fong GT, Choi YJ. Methodology: Quah ACK, Fong GT, Choi YJ, Oh JK, Le Tu H. Project administration: Choi YJ. Visualization: Le Tu H. Writing – original draft: Le Tu H, Choi YJ, Oh JK, Quah ACK, Fong GT. Writing – review & editing: Le Tu H, Oh JK, Seo HG, Kim GY, Cho SI, Lee S, Kim Y, Meng G, Quah ACK, Fong GT, Choi YJ.

Figure 1
Adjusted associations for comparative risk perceptions of HTPs and EC vs. SC among Koreans who smoke cigarettes, 2024 International Tobacco Control Korea Survey. Estimates are from the primary Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings ordinal logistic regression model with informative priors. Points indicate adjusted odds ratios and horizontal lines indicate 95% credible intervals (CrI). SC, cigarette-only users; HTP, heated tobacco products; EC, electronic cigarettes; TIS, time in sample.
jpmph-26-338f1.jpg
Figure 2
Sensitivity analysis of comparative risk perceptions of (A) HTPs vs. SC and (B) ECs vs. SC across three analytical approaches, 2024 International Tobacco Control Korea Survey. SC, cigarette-only users; HTP, heated tobacco products; EC, electronic cigarettes; TIS, time in sample; M-H, Metropolis-Hastings; Crl, credible intervals; CI, confidence interval.
jpmph-26-338f2.jpg
Table 1
Socio-demographic characteristics of eligible Korean respondents by type of cigarette use, 2024 International Tobacco Control (ITC) Korea Survey (n=3010)
Characteristics Product use
Cigarette only (SC) Dual use (SC+HTP) Dual use (SC+EC) Total Likelihood-ratio test
Total 1801 (59.8) 1156 (38.4) 53 (1.8) 3010 (100)
Age, mean±SD (y) 49.5±11.3 43.9±10.2 40.5±12.1 47.2±11.3 <0.001
Age (y) <0.001
 19–39 332 (18.4) 375 (32.4) 23 (43.4) 730 (24.3)
 40–59 1101 (61.1) 697 (60.3) 28 (52.8) 1826 (60.7)
 ≥60 368 (20.4) 84 (7.3) 2 (3.8) 454 (15.1)
Sex 0.018
 Male 1583 (87.9) 980 (84.8) 42 (79.2) 2605 (86.5)
 Female 218 (12.1) 176 (15.2) 11 (20.8) 405 (13.5)
Highest educational level <0.001
 Low or medium 502 (27.9) 186 (16.1) 26 (49.1) 714 (23.7)
 High 1299 (72.1) 970 (83.9) 27 (50.9) 2296 (76.3)
Household income <0.001
 Low 286 (16.1) 81 (7.1) 7 (13.5) 374 (12.6)
 Moderate 967 (54.4) 619 (53.9) 29 (55.8) 1615 (54.3)
 High 523 (29.4) 448 (39.0) 16 (30.8) 987 (33.2)
Partner/spouse who currently smokes 0.016
 Yes 154 (8.6) 136 (11.8) 6 (11.3) 296 (9.8)
 No 1647 (91.4) 1020 (88.2) 47 (88.7) 2714 (90.2)
Alcohol drinking status 0.019
 Never drinker 139 (7.9) 65 (5.7) 1 (1.9) 205 (7.0)
 Drinker 1622 (92.1) 1069 (94.3) 51 (98.1) 2742 (93.0)
TIS1 <0.001
 1 696 (38.6) 523 (45.2) 23 (43.4) 1242 (41.3)
 2 384 (21.3) 272 (23.5) 13 (24.5) 669 (22.2)
 3 296 (16.4) 147 (12.7) 8 (15.1) 451 (15.0)
 4 425 (22.3) 214 (18.5) 9 (17.0) 648 (21.5)

Values are presented as number (%); Percentages are calculated among respondents with non-missing data for each characteristic; therefore, denominators may vary across variables because of item-level missingness.

SC, cigarette-only users; SC+HTP, cigarettes+heated tobacco products; SC+EC, cigarettes+electronic cigarettes; TIS, time in sample.

1 Refers to the number of ITC Korea Survey waves in which the respondent had participated; TIS=1 indicates first-time participation in the survey cohort at the current wave; TIS=2, TIS=3, and TIS=4 indicate participation in the second, third, and fourth survey wave, respectively.

Table 2
Product use characteristics of eligible Korean respondents by product use group, 2024 ITC Korea Survey (n=3010)
Characteristics Product usage
Cigarette only (SC) Dual use (SC+HTP) Dual use (SC+EC) Total Likelihood-ratio test
Total 1801 (59.8) 1156 (38.4) 53 (1.8) 3010 (100)
Frequency of SC <0.001
 Daily 1663 (92.3) 1013 (87.6) 43 (81.1) 2719 (90.3)
 Less than daily 138 (7.7) 143 (12.4) 10 (18.9) 291 (9.7)
Frequency of HTP use -
 Daily N/A 760 (65.7) N/A 760 (65.7)
 Less than daily N/A 396 (34.3) N/A 396 (34.3)
Frequency of EC use -
 Daily N/A N/A 29 (54.7) 29 (54.7)
 Less than daily N/A N/A 24 (45.3) 24 (45.3)
Ever tried to quit smoking 0.348
 Yes 972 (54.9) 652 (57.4) 31 (59.6) 1655 (55.9)
 No 800 (45.1) 484 (42.6) 21 (40.4) 1305 (44.1)
Heaviness of Smoking Index <0.001
 Low 1150 (64.7) 851 (75.0) 33 (63.5) 2034 (68.6)
 Moderate 593 (33.4) 280 (24.7) 18 (34.6) 891 (30.1)
 High 35 (2.0) 3 (0.3) 1 (1.9) 39 (1.3)
Exposure to any types of tobacco/nicotine warnings 0.675
 Not exposed 7 (0.5) 7 (0.7) 0 (0) 14 (0.6)
 Exposed 1368 (99.5) 1009 (99.3) 40 (100) 2417 (99.4)
Noticed cigarettes being advertised in any channel <0.001
 Did not notice 712 (39.5) 278 (24.0) 14 (26.4) 1004 (33.4)
 Noticed 1089 (60.5) 878 (76.0) 39 (73.6) 2006 (66.6)
Noticed HTPs being advertised in any channel <0.001
 Did not notice 594 (33.0) 140 (12.1) 4 (7.5) 738 (24.5)
 Noticed 1207 (67.0) 1016 (87.9) 49 (92.5) 2272 (75.5)
Noticed ECs being advertised in any channel <0.001
 Did not notice 1027 (57.0) 530 (45.8) 14 (26.4) 1571 (52.2)
 Noticed 774 (43.0) 626 (54.2) 39 (73.6) 1439 (47.8)

Values are presented as number (%); Percentages are calculated among respondents with non-missing data for each characteristic; therefore, denominators may vary across variables because of item-level missingness.

ITC, International Tobacco Control; SC, cigarette-only users; SC+HTP, cigarettes+heated tobacco products; SC+EC, cigarettes+electronic cigarettes; N/A, not applicable.

Figure & Data

References

    Citations

    Citations to this article as recorded by  

      Figure
      • 0
      • 1
      Comparative Risk Perceptions of Alternative Nicotine Products Among People Who Smoke Cigarettes and Dual Products: Findings From the 2024 ITC Korea Survey
      Image Image
      Figure 1 Adjusted associations for comparative risk perceptions of HTPs and EC vs. SC among Koreans who smoke cigarettes, 2024 International Tobacco Control Korea Survey. Estimates are from the primary Bayesian Metropolis-Hastings ordinal logistic regression model with informative priors. Points indicate adjusted odds ratios and horizontal lines indicate 95% credible intervals (CrI). SC, cigarette-only users; HTP, heated tobacco products; EC, electronic cigarettes; TIS, time in sample.
      Figure 2 Sensitivity analysis of comparative risk perceptions of (A) HTPs vs. SC and (B) ECs vs. SC across three analytical approaches, 2024 International Tobacco Control Korea Survey. SC, cigarette-only users; HTP, heated tobacco products; EC, electronic cigarettes; TIS, time in sample; M-H, Metropolis-Hastings; Crl, credible intervals; CI, confidence interval.
      Comparative Risk Perceptions of Alternative Nicotine Products Among People Who Smoke Cigarettes and Dual Products: Findings From the 2024 ITC Korea Survey
      Characteristics Product use
      Cigarette only (SC) Dual use (SC+HTP) Dual use (SC+EC) Total Likelihood-ratio test
      Total 1801 (59.8) 1156 (38.4) 53 (1.8) 3010 (100)
      Age, mean±SD (y) 49.5±11.3 43.9±10.2 40.5±12.1 47.2±11.3 <0.001
      Age (y) <0.001
       19–39 332 (18.4) 375 (32.4) 23 (43.4) 730 (24.3)
       40–59 1101 (61.1) 697 (60.3) 28 (52.8) 1826 (60.7)
       ≥60 368 (20.4) 84 (7.3) 2 (3.8) 454 (15.1)
      Sex 0.018
       Male 1583 (87.9) 980 (84.8) 42 (79.2) 2605 (86.5)
       Female 218 (12.1) 176 (15.2) 11 (20.8) 405 (13.5)
      Highest educational level <0.001
       Low or medium 502 (27.9) 186 (16.1) 26 (49.1) 714 (23.7)
       High 1299 (72.1) 970 (83.9) 27 (50.9) 2296 (76.3)
      Household income <0.001
       Low 286 (16.1) 81 (7.1) 7 (13.5) 374 (12.6)
       Moderate 967 (54.4) 619 (53.9) 29 (55.8) 1615 (54.3)
       High 523 (29.4) 448 (39.0) 16 (30.8) 987 (33.2)
      Partner/spouse who currently smokes 0.016
       Yes 154 (8.6) 136 (11.8) 6 (11.3) 296 (9.8)
       No 1647 (91.4) 1020 (88.2) 47 (88.7) 2714 (90.2)
      Alcohol drinking status 0.019
       Never drinker 139 (7.9) 65 (5.7) 1 (1.9) 205 (7.0)
       Drinker 1622 (92.1) 1069 (94.3) 51 (98.1) 2742 (93.0)
      TIS1 <0.001
       1 696 (38.6) 523 (45.2) 23 (43.4) 1242 (41.3)
       2 384 (21.3) 272 (23.5) 13 (24.5) 669 (22.2)
       3 296 (16.4) 147 (12.7) 8 (15.1) 451 (15.0)
       4 425 (22.3) 214 (18.5) 9 (17.0) 648 (21.5)
      Characteristics Product usage
      Cigarette only (SC) Dual use (SC+HTP) Dual use (SC+EC) Total Likelihood-ratio test
      Total 1801 (59.8) 1156 (38.4) 53 (1.8) 3010 (100)
      Frequency of SC <0.001
       Daily 1663 (92.3) 1013 (87.6) 43 (81.1) 2719 (90.3)
       Less than daily 138 (7.7) 143 (12.4) 10 (18.9) 291 (9.7)
      Frequency of HTP use -
       Daily N/A 760 (65.7) N/A 760 (65.7)
       Less than daily N/A 396 (34.3) N/A 396 (34.3)
      Frequency of EC use -
       Daily N/A N/A 29 (54.7) 29 (54.7)
       Less than daily N/A N/A 24 (45.3) 24 (45.3)
      Ever tried to quit smoking 0.348
       Yes 972 (54.9) 652 (57.4) 31 (59.6) 1655 (55.9)
       No 800 (45.1) 484 (42.6) 21 (40.4) 1305 (44.1)
      Heaviness of Smoking Index <0.001
       Low 1150 (64.7) 851 (75.0) 33 (63.5) 2034 (68.6)
       Moderate 593 (33.4) 280 (24.7) 18 (34.6) 891 (30.1)
       High 35 (2.0) 3 (0.3) 1 (1.9) 39 (1.3)
      Exposure to any types of tobacco/nicotine warnings 0.675
       Not exposed 7 (0.5) 7 (0.7) 0 (0) 14 (0.6)
       Exposed 1368 (99.5) 1009 (99.3) 40 (100) 2417 (99.4)
      Noticed cigarettes being advertised in any channel <0.001
       Did not notice 712 (39.5) 278 (24.0) 14 (26.4) 1004 (33.4)
       Noticed 1089 (60.5) 878 (76.0) 39 (73.6) 2006 (66.6)
      Noticed HTPs being advertised in any channel <0.001
       Did not notice 594 (33.0) 140 (12.1) 4 (7.5) 738 (24.5)
       Noticed 1207 (67.0) 1016 (87.9) 49 (92.5) 2272 (75.5)
      Noticed ECs being advertised in any channel <0.001
       Did not notice 1027 (57.0) 530 (45.8) 14 (26.4) 1571 (52.2)
       Noticed 774 (43.0) 626 (54.2) 39 (73.6) 1439 (47.8)
      Table 1 Socio-demographic characteristics of eligible Korean respondents by type of cigarette use, 2024 International Tobacco Control (ITC) Korea Survey (n=3010)

      Values are presented as number (%); Percentages are calculated among respondents with non-missing data for each characteristic; therefore, denominators may vary across variables because of item-level missingness.

      SC, cigarette-only users; SC+HTP, cigarettes+heated tobacco products; SC+EC, cigarettes+electronic cigarettes; TIS, time in sample.

      Refers to the number of ITC Korea Survey waves in which the respondent had participated; TIS=1 indicates first-time participation in the survey cohort at the current wave; TIS=2, TIS=3, and TIS=4 indicate participation in the second, third, and fourth survey wave, respectively.

      Table 2 Product use characteristics of eligible Korean respondents by product use group, 2024 ITC Korea Survey (n=3010)

      Values are presented as number (%); Percentages are calculated among respondents with non-missing data for each characteristic; therefore, denominators may vary across variables because of item-level missingness.

      ITC, International Tobacco Control; SC, cigarette-only users; SC+HTP, cigarettes+heated tobacco products; SC+EC, cigarettes+electronic cigarettes; N/A, not applicable.


      JPMPH : Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health
      TOP